This teen’s death wasn’t euthanasia — but it was still deeply wrong

This teen’s death wasn’t euthanasia — but it was still deeply wrong


 When people are suffering mental anguish and want to kill themselves, should we simply let them die?  Noa Pothoven was a troubled 17-year-old in the Netherlands She had suffered sexual assault at 11 and rape at 14. She was afflicted with anorexia She had begged to die and succeeded in taking her life last Sunday.  The story that first exploded worldwide was that Pothoven was euthanized by the Dutch state  But the original outrage subsided after subsequent news stories highlighted her death hadn’t actually been approved by the official euthanasia authority in the Netherlands She had previously asked a clinic in The Hague to euthanize her but was denied because she didn’t have her parents’ permission  Had Pothoven tried again, she may have gotten that approval. Natalie O’Neill reported for The Post that The Netherlands “allows children from 12 through 16 to kill themselves with permission from a parent and if a doctor agrees that their suffering is unbearable and likely to continue At age 17, children no longer need their parents’ consent.”  Naomi O’Leary, a correspondent with Politico Europe, who was among the first to challenge the euthanasia story, tweeted, “Pothoven insisted she wanted no further treatment and a hospital bed was set up at home in the care of her parents At the start of June she began refusing all fluids and food, and her parents and doctors agreed not to force feed her ”  The state was not involved in killing Pothoven but is what ultimately happened so much better?  Whether this was euthanasia or regular suicide, something went terribly wrong here  A Gallup poll last year found that 72 percent of Americans “continue to believe that doctors should be legally allowed, at a patient’s and a family’s request, to end a terminally ill patient’s life using painless means ” We picture the ailing elderly, the hopeless cancer patient, the people suffering debilitating, life-destroying diseases It’s a mercy killing. The person can take no more.  We do not picture a 17-year-old, agonized with mental illness after trauma The very definition of euthanasia, “the painless killing of a patient suffering from an incurable and painful disease or in an irreversible coma,” doesn’t apply  The story didn’t horrify people all over the world because the state was involved but because a teenager was allowed to die Whether it was because of intervention or because a decision was made not to stop her death is irrelevant  A few days before her death, she posted to Instagram that she was planning to end her life In a since-deleted post, Pothoven wrote “I will get straight to the point: Within a maximum of 10 days I will die ” She didn’t die suddenly from anorexia. She planned to die, and then she did. She starved herself to death while people around her watched Is it so different than leaping from a bridge and having everyone step aside? see also Pope says assisted suicide is ‘defeat for all’ after Dutch teen Noa Pothoven’s death Pope Francis condemned assisted suicide as a “defeat for all”  According to a report released in January by the World Health Organization, suicide is “the second-leading cause of death among 15- to 29-year-olds globally ” In America, it’s the second-leading cause of death among 10- to 34-year-olds. As recently as 2010, it was the 10th-leading cause It is a growing problem and one that is contagious. Studies have shown that high-profile suicides lead to more suicides Pothoven’s death could easily have that same result.  We want people to have autonomy and ease their suffering as much as possible But that doesn’t mean we just allow people to kill themselves. Mental illness is difficult to combat, but giving up on a 17-year-old should never be normal or acceptable  Pothoven’s death was not death by appointment. The media got that wrong. But what it actually was should still shock and appall us

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *